Trends in Digital Media 2007


Dr. Elizabeth Hanson-Smith
CSU, Sacramento &
Command Performance Language Institute


The world of CALL is changing rapidly, but there are three major trends that can be perceived as significant and likely to remain so over the next several years. This paper will discuss these trends--convergence, searchability, and collaboration--and offer examples of interesting websites that illustrate them.

Convergence

Almost everyone has by now taken a video with a mobile phone and loaded it to a computer and/or posted it to the Internet. mobile phones are being used in a variety of new ways: tagging an object to place or retrieve a message, locating the price of a product by reading a bar code, and even watching live TV casts. Several innovations over the past few years have made mobility a very hot trend, particularly the extensive coverage of global positioning satellites and cellular networks as well as the nano-technologies to make handheld devices ever smaller and increasingly more powerful. Verizon Wireless in the USA has entered the mobile TV market with eight channels of live television beamed to subscribers' phones. Twitter is a free service that sends short instant messages on the theme "What are you doing right now?" via its Website to networks of "friends" on mobile phones.

Various other technologies allow the user to place shift, for example, to send a TV program remotely to an Internet-connected PC, mobile phone, or PDA. One such set-top device is Slingbox (see Figure 1). Other similar devices are made by Apple Computers, et  al. New TVs will probably come already equipped with this feature.



slingboxes
Figure 1. Slingboxes sit on the TV and connect wirelessly to a computer or mobile device.
Photo from  http://us.slingmedia.com/page/statichome.

If you have traveled recently and stayed in hotels, you may have found a TV channel that promotes local city attractions. The use of digital video has allows immediate and totally localized commercials to be professionally produced by such companies as Turnhere.com at a fraction of the usual cost of television commercials. Local places and events of interest can be quickly "videotaped" digitally and turned into attractive products with desktop editing tools. The technologies that make global-local (glocal) effects possible will obviously  have importance for education (see the section below on collaboration).

Podcasting (iPod + broadcast)  is another aspect of convergence that is rapidly taking hold in blended courses at universities and colleges (see for example, an interview with Eiko Kato of Osaka Jogakuin College [McCarty, 2006]). Podcast courses allow students (and the general public in some instances) to downoad faculty lectures and media as syndicated files to play on an iPod or computer. Students can respond orally and in text, again via podcast or mobile phone or computer. Many of the larger universities--e.g., Stanford, York University in Canada, and the British Open University--have already heavily invested in this technology, and numerous language institutions are following suit (see Stanford on iTunes U). The advantages, of course, are that students may listen in at their own convenience, hear a lecture or examine a whiteboard drawing as often as they desire, and connect back with great immediacy to their professor when office hours might be inconvenient. Teachers will have to understand if not master, the technologies used, which are, like TV on the iPod, intuitive and easy for beginners. Ming Nie (2006) offers an excellent summary and overview of the many ways podcasts are being or could be used for education; the Apple Education site has useful help sheets and FAQs. Video-capable iPods (released in October 2006) and the soon-to-be-released iPhone, a combination of 3-1/2" TV screen, podcatcher, and mobile phone, will, of course, additionally enhance the present wave of podcast educational materials.

Another exciting use of converging technologies is the videocasting of faculty lectures or videoconferencing such as displayed at Leslie Opp-Beckman's site, Thai-UO (2005; see Figure 2). Opp-Beckman presents a series of lectures from the University of Oregon's American English Institute videocast on the Web to two different sites in Thailand. The resulting video was then saved and can be recycled as a reusable learning object (RLO), along with considerable additional apparatus, such as lecture notes, PowerPoint (Microsoft 2007) slides, discussion questions, suggestions for students projects, and links to online resources and to examples of students' projects resulting from the conferences.


Thai-UO
Figure 2. Leslie Opp-Beckman (top right), as seen video conferencing on the Web from the University of Oregon to two locations in Thailand (left and bottom right). The video recording of the event becomes a reusable learning object. http://thaiuo.uoregon.edu/session_01.html.
(© 2005 Copyright American English Institute and CET Interactive Media.)

Voice over Internet protocols (VOIPs) that allow telephone calls over the net are now becoming an increasingly familiar type of convergence. Skype, an Internet telephony, allows up to nine users to conference-call on its free service. Free phone calls anywhere in the world allow students to interact in new and unforeseen ways. For instance, Rita Zeinstejer had her students in Argentina Skype their counterparts studying Spanish language and culture in the US. They also wrote about their conversations and self-evaluated their participation in a blog, CAE B's podcast, with both audio and text comments and photos. Here is a sample from Denise:

The project we are doing is an amazing idea in order to learn the language in another way. To my mind, that’s very important to know to how to communicate correctly in English with other people, especially if they are from abroad. This opportunity[talking via Skype] that we had was a perfect occasion to do it!

We were able to do something that, I think, not many students would ever do. Luckily, I and my classmates could do it! We talked with Spanish students from the USA. We exchanged opinions about many different and interesting topics. 

 -- Denise, May 02, 2006 (http://caeb2006.podomatic.com/entry/2006-05-02T18_28_37-07_00)

Increasingly, we will see combinations of phone and Internet, as for example, at the mobile site simulation put up as an experiment by Steve McCarty at Language Learning Japan, where the user may leave a phone or text message directly on the Web using the mobile address, http://winksite.com/waoe/mall.


Searchability

Looking for something? With all the exciting new media being generated, how does one find anything on the Web? Producer-created tagging seems to be the current standard, and unless computers become very much smarter, how the creator labels and organizes content will be of increasing significance in the coming decade. To understand how important searchability is, let us look at the several ways content can be tagged.

We are all familiar with the alphabetic list of topics. VideoPedia (which seems to have no content yet) organizes its list in a series of menus on the left side of its home page. Users and video-producers are expected to add content by selecting the page that seems most closely related to their video. This is a primitive type of tagging.  Vidipedia also has a list of user-organized topics (see Figure 3), but within these, users may tag their content so that it links to pages with "articles" about the video's content. Of more value, of course, would be a way to tag the content so the video itself was findable, which is exactly what Google Video has done. Thus a search term like electric car  in Vidipedia will lead to a text article, while in Google Video it will find videos that show such cars--if, and only if, the producer has properly tagged the video. One nice feature of Google Video is that the user can search by title and by keywords in the text description of a video, so one has several possible ways to locate a video on a given topic. However, the search is limited to videos loaded onto Google Video or YouTube.

74Vidipedia
Figure 3. Vidipedia's front page has an alphabetized list of topics (upper left), and also allows for tagging that links to  related articles. http://www.vidipedia.org/Main_Page. (GNU FDL).


Another strategy for tagging is illustrated by CBBC, the BBC's site with children's content.  Workers tag the site content internally, so that a search for animals, for example, will lead to articles and videos about pets and wildlife yet keep the searcher within the children's area of the site. In contrast to CBBC or Google Video, which limit users to particular sites, Blinkx allows the user to search over 7 million videos (and podcasts) stored at dozens of archives around the Internet. The sheer magnitude of the search brings home the significance of tagging, that is, how producers themselves define their content. For example, with the search terms culture and Thailand I found 74 videos. One of these had some 35 tags, including Less than 10 Seconds, Non US Location, Real Time, and Cinematography. Also among the search results was a podcast from Stanford University with no apparent relationship to the two search terms; yet with a little digging, I found the term culture in the sidebar list of topics at the Web site where the podcast was housed. This kind of breadth and depth of search can be daunting, and emphasizes the necessity of good producer tagging.

Tags are especially important for non-text files, e.g., video, photos, graphics, audio, and music. Some sites use visual referencing to indicate the number of related tags. For example, at the jamendo search engine, the relative size of the tag indicates the relative number of matches within their database as seen in Figure 4.

jamendo links
Figure 4. jamendo demonstrates the number of matches to their database by the size of the producer-defined tag. http://www.jamendo.com/.

One of the chief ways to use tagging is to find others with like interests. Once found, a photo blog, vlog, or podcast can then be followed via RSS (really simple syndication), with one of the many applications such as Bloglines and Furl that find and retrieve new information from user-designated sites. (Bloglines is an aggregator that sends the new information to a Website visited by the user; Furl sends new information to the user's email address.) One recently organized EFL composition project, WritingMatrix, is using precisely this combination of tagging and RSS to stimulate student blogging. In future, face recognition software and speech-to-text capabilities will enable search engines to find video and audio content, but these are still far from perfect. Until this more sophisticated type of software becomes readily available, tags enable organization of the myriad sites on the Web and increasingly are enabling collaborations to take place.

Collaboration

In the good old days, the Web was a read-only environment where only a few specialists were able to write the code and control the servers that fed information to the Internet. Today, the Internet is a place where even novice users can easily create, upload, mashup, and share information through a wide variety of media (see Thompson 2007). One type of mashup (if I may extend the term to its increasingly common meaning of mixing and matching a variety of Web products and tools) mentioned earlier is to be found exemplified in CAE B's podcast, which combines Skyping with text, photos, and audio blogging in a blended (online and on land) learning environment. The podcast enhances the composition process for students by using visual and aural media, and it demands those kinds of tools students are increasingly bringing to the educational table: digital cameras, audio recorders, and mobile phones. One question to consider is how ready are "Education 1.0 teachers" for the new collaborative Internet, often called Web 2.0? (Thompson 2007, p. 1.)

Collaborations are taking place through a very wide variety of tools, and new additions are popping up almost daily, for example, Kyte allows the user to set up a personal television channel to instantly share mobile phone-created videos with family and friends. The bonus, not found on YouTube, for example, is that the producer can broadcast live from a mobile phone and live text chat with multiple viewers. As with other video-hosting sites, the product has collaborative features: it can be embedding in a Website, wiki, or blog, and has an interactive polling feature. Kyte also has an option that allows the user to email photos as a slideshow. Increasingly, we are seeing educators take advantage of these new, media-driven ways of collaborating.

The Moodle-based ESL Slideshow Exchange Project was created by Sergio Mazarelli to offer a site where Web or software media-based slideshows might form the basis for discussion in EFL/ESL classroom collaborations. The project offers help pages for getting started in creating slideshows with familiar desktop tools such as Windows Movie Maker (Microsoft 2004), iMovie (Apple 2006), and PowerPoint (Microsoft 2007). An open-ended collaboration, where teachers and students choose the media to be used, may be arranged at Dekita.org's EFL/ESL Exchange, which was set up specifically to help form classroom-to-classroom exchanges. The Dekita.org blog owners, Barbara Dieu, Aaron Campbell, and Rudolf Amman, provide samples from interesting exchanges to whet the appetite. Interestingly, both both the ESL Slideshow and the Dekita exchange projects originated during TESOL CALL Interest Section's Electronic Village Online sessions in prior years (for examples, see Hanson-Smith & Bauer-Ramazani 2004 and the announcement page for EVO: TESOL Electronic Village 2007), demonstrating yet another way that the Web has brought together people from all over the world.

While a number of sites offer keypal connections and a variety of ways for classrooms to collaborate, there are also some teacher collectives, or communities of practice that encourage technology-using teachers to join forces. (For an extended discussion of communities of practice, as opposed to casual classroom "communities," see Hanson-Smith, 2006.) Often technology-using teachers are isolated in their own teaching situation, but online communities offer a means to self-access professional development as well as a way to form long-lasting global friendships. Groups like EVO Video 2007, an online community for video-using teachers (see their wiki pages for student work, lesson plans, etc.), provide a way for teachers to experiment with peer guidance in the new media, and perhaps more importantly, to connect with kindred spirits. Learning with Computers is a community that begins a new online "course" every 8-12 weeks, guiding teachers through a wide variety of Web tools, sharing experiments and classroom practices (see also their wiki, Learning with Computers: FrontPage for resources). The mother--or grandmother--of these communities is the Webheads in Action, whose formation by Vance Stevens in 2001-2002 (again, as part of the Electronic Village Online) sparked a chain of new groups and provided a means for signficant and sustained collaborations. The Webheads meet weekly online to experiment with new Web tools and media, and now present their own biennial online "convergence," the WiAOC, where members and a stellar group of invited guest speakers present their work to a global population via text chats and voice conferencing. While other, more passive kinds of collaborations, such as MERLOT's collection of RLOs or the Sloan-C Wiki, offer ways for teachers to share best practices in online teaching and learning, the personal touch that interactive digital media can provide is superior and should always be considered an important adjunct to any asynchronous archive.

Although the focus of this paper is education, we should not forget the many ways in which the Web is allowing collaboration and interaction for personal--and political-- reasons. The glocal effect is evident not only in the many blogs where anyone can rant and gain an intense following worldwide, but in organizations like Kiva, which with a simple click at their Website allows the user to loan all or a portion of needed funds to a micro-business person in far off countries. The lender receives emails from the recipient charting progress. If the small business is successful, the loan is repaid, all with little or no overhead through the connectivity of the Internet. This type of organization seems to give credence to the idea that the Internet is changing how we interact as people.

In closing, I can think of no better way to summarize these important trends than to suggest a viewing of the very short viral video: Web 2.0... The Machine is US/ing US. Web 2.0 is not the future; it is now.



References

Apple Computer Inc. 2006. iMovie HD 6 [Computer software]. http://www.apple.com/ilife/imovie/.

Apple Computers. 2007. Apple Inc. http://www.apple.com/.

Apple Education. 2007. Apple Inc.  http://www.apple.com/education/.

Blinkx. 2007. http://www.blinkx.com/.

Bloglines. 2007. IAC Search & Media. http://www.bloglines.com.

CAE B's podcast. 2007, February 05. R. Zeinstejer. http://caeb2006.podomatic.com/.

CBBC. 2007. British Broadcasting Corporation. http://www.bbc.co.uk/cbbc/.

Dekita.org:Open EFL/ESL. 2007. B. Dieu, A. Campbell, and R. Amman. http://dekita.org/.

EFL/ESL Exchange. 2007. Dekita.org. http://dekita.org/exchange.

ESL Slideshow Exchange Projectn.d. S. Mazzarelli. http://www.deepmoat.com/moodle/.

EVO: TESOL Electronic Village Online 2007. 2007. D. González, et al. http://dafnegonzalez.com/evo-07/index1.htm.

EVO Video 2007. 2006. R. Detwiler, N. Gromik, & M. Marzio. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/evovideo07.

Furl. 2007. LookSmart, Ltd. http://www.furl.net/.

Google Video. 2007. Google. http://video.google.com.

Hanson-Smith, E. 2006. Communities of practice for pre- and in-service teacher education. In P. Hubbard & M. Levy, eds., Teacher Education in CALL, 301-315.  John Benjamins. See also Community of Practice Resources.

Hanson-Smith, E., and C. Bauer-Ramazani. 2004. Professional development: The Electronic Village Online
of the TESOL CALL Interest Section. TESL-EJ  8(2). http://cwp60.berkeley.edu:16080/TESL-EJ/ej30/int.html.

iPhone. 2007. Apple Inc. http://www.apple.com/iphone/ipod/.

jamendo. 2007. http://www.jamendo.com/en/.

Kiva. 2004-2007. Kiva (M. Flannery, et al.) http://www.kiva.org/.

Kyte. 2006, 2007. Decentral.tv Corp. http://www.kyte.tv/home/index.html.

Language Learning Japan. 2007. S. McCarty, and Wireless Ink Corporation. http://winksite.com/site/site_profile.cfm?susid=17798.

Learning with Computers. 2006-2007. G. Baya, C. Bellusci, & M. Hillis. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/learningwithcomputers/.

Learning with Computers: Frontpage.  2007. G. Baya, et al. http://learningwithcomputers.pbwiki.com/.

McCarty, S. 2006. Interview with Professor Eiko Kato, First in the World to Apply iPods to Education. Glocom Platform: Japanese Institute of Global Communications, Colloquium #64, March 7, 2006. http://www.glocom.org/special_topics/colloquium/20060307_mccarty_interview/.

MERLOT: Multimedia Education Resource for Learning and Online Teaching. 2007. MERLOT. http://www.merlot.org/merlot/index.htm.

Microsoft Corp. 2004. Windows Movie Maker 2.1 [Computer software]. http://www.microsoft.com/windowsxp/downloads/updates/moviemaker2.mspx.

Microsoft Corp. 2007. Microsoft Office PowerPoint 2007 [Computer software]. http://office.microsoft.com/en-us/powerpoint/default.aspx.

Moodle. 2004. Moodle. http://moodle.com/.

Nie, M. 2006. The Potential Use of Mobile Devices in Higher Education: Audio/Podcasting material in Higher Education, A Draft Review (August 2006). Univerity of Leicester. Downloadable at  http://www2.le.ac.uk/projects/impala/presentations/Berlin/The%20Potential%20Use%20of%20Mobile%20Devices%20in%20Higher%20Education.

Skype. 2007. Skype Ltd. http://www.skype.com/.

Slingbox. 2005-2007. Sling Media.  http://us.slingmedia.com/page/statichome.

Sloan-C Wiki. 2007. http://www.sloan-c-wiki.org/.

Stanford on iTunes U.  n.d.  Stanford University. http://itunes.stanford.edu/rss/.

Thai-UO. 2005. L. Opp-Beckman. American English Institute and CET Interactive Media. http://thaiuo.uoregon.edu/.

Thompson, J. 2007. Is Education 1.0 Ready for Web 2.0 Students? Innovate 3(4). http://innovateonline.info/index.php?view=article&id=393.

Twitter. 2007. Twitter/Obvious. http://twitter.com.

Verizon Wireless. 2007. Verizon Wireless. http://www.verizonwireless.com/b2c/index.html.

VideoPedia. 2005-2007. http://www.videopedia.com/.

Vidipedia. 2007. http://www.vidipedia.org/Main_Page.

Web 2.0... The Machine is US/ing US. 2007. M. Wesch. http://youtube.com/watch?v=NLlGopyXT_g#%7CWeb.

Webheads in Action. 2002. V. Stevens.   http://groups.yahoo.com/group/evonline2002_webheads.

WiAOC. 2005-2007. http://wiaoc.org.

WritingMatrix. 2007. V. Stevens, N. Quintana, R. Zeinstejer, D. Molero, S. Sirk, and Tangient LLC. http://writingmatrix.wikispaces.com/.

YouTube. 2007 YouTube, Inc. http://youtube.com/.


Dr. Elizabeth Hanson-Smith, professor emeritus at CSU, Sacramento,  was lead designer for the Oxford Picture Dictionary Interactive and pedagogical consultant for Live Action English Interactive. She wrote Constructing the Paragraph, a tutorial for composition. With Mike Marzio, she co-moderates Real English Online, for video-using students, and EVO Video 07, a group supporting language teachers using video. Author of many articles on CALL pedagogy, her books include Learning Languages through Technology (co-editor Sarah Rilling, 2006), and CALL Environments. 2nd ed. (co-editor Joy Egbert, 2007), both available from TESOL >Publications. Website: Computers for Education.